Once upon a time there were two children of a farmer. The one named Emmett was very hardworking, and helped their father plant the fields each spring, tend the crops each summer, and harvest the crops each fall. The other was named Francis and was very lazy, preferring to spend his days climbing trees by the river and chasing rabbits through the fields.
One day, Emmett was out tending the crops when his brother stopped by on his way down to the river and said “I hope the crops come in well this year.” Then, he continued on his way, but every day that he passed his brother in the fields, he gave this greeting.
As the harvest approached, the trees in the orchards became heavy with fruit, the corn grew tall on the stalks, and Emmett was again tending the crops to prepare for the harvest. Francis stopped and said, “I hope the harvest is good this year,” before continuing down to the river.
Emmett and his father labored heavily during the harvest, but this year they’d gotten the largest crop to date. They would be able to sell the extra for a profit that Emmett and his father planned to split between themselves, as they’d put in all of the effort.
They reveled in their success until Francis approached and said, “Well, I see that my blessing was successful. The harvest has indeed been good. What is my share of the profit?”
Both Emmett and their father looked at each other in shock. Surely Francis could not think that he had earned part of the profit that they worked all year for. Emmett broke the stunned silence, “Brother, I cannot imagine why you think your share would be anything more than zero.”
Francis replied, “Every day when I passed you, I said that I hope the crops come in well this year”
“Well, yes, you did, but that does not mean you contributed in the least!”
Emmett said, “We’ll put this to a fight, and the last man standing wins.” And though their father hated to watch his children fight, he did not want to give Francis the idea that he could be rewarded for his laziness.
The boys started fighting, and it seemed as though Emmett was going to lose until his father stuck his foot out behind Francis and tripped him as he backed up. Emmett recovered and won the fight.
Francis could only sulk as he had been outwitted. He failed to realize his father’s part in the outcome of the fight, and went down to the river to wash the dirt off of himself.
“And so every one who is greedy is put to shame.”
Author’s Note:
(Original story illustration by Hilda Roberts) |
This story is called Tortoise Bowl-On-The-Back and the Fox, and it’s about a tortoise named Bowl-On-The-Back who works hard to harvest a good crop, and throughout the year is visited by the Fox who always says “May God give you strength.” After the harvest is over, the Fox shows back up and asks for his share of the crop, which the tortoise refuses. Then, the Fox challenges Bowl-On-The-Back to a race for the right to all of the grain. Knowing he will lose, the tortoise tells his brother to wait at the end of the race and pretend that he is Bowl-On-The-Back because the Fox won’t be able to tell them apart. And so the brothers trick the Fox into letting them keep their crop.
I decided to change up the story by making it a sort of Cain and Abel-type story of brothers fighting with each other. Francis represents the Fox and Emmett is Bowl-On-The-Back, while their father is the accomplice in defeating Francis. I decided to have them fight instead of race because it seems more like something that brothers would do and it would be harder to trick Francis in a foot race. The last line of the story was taken directly from the original story because I really felt like it summed up the point of the story in a really direct, succinct way.
Bibliography:
Tortoise Bowl-On-The-Back and the Fox, Persian Tales, translated by D.L.R. Lorimer and E.O. Lorimer and illustrated by Hilda Roberts (1919).
In your Author’s Note, you gave such a descriptive summary of the original story, which was great! I feel like I really got to understand the roots behind your version of Tortoise Bowl-On-The-Back and the Fox. The name of the story is quite peculiar, which would have grabbed my attention as well. By mixing in the Biblical story of Cain and Abel for inspiration, you gave the story more of a dynamic twist.
ReplyDeleteI like how you really used your preferences and input to tell a well crafted story. I agreed with how you make Emmitt and Francis solve their dispute in a fight, because that's what brothers would do! It all made wonderful sense how you made the original conflict in the "Tortoise Bowl-On-The-Back and The Fox" tale more effective: everything was building up to that last confrontation and you executed that simply, yet energetically! Keep it up!
ReplyDeleteAwesome job. I really enjoyed your story and liked how you adapted it. Your version was creative change to the original, and I enjoyed how you made it about two brothers like Cain and Abel. I thought you did a good job of describing each character and creating imagery. Although I didn't have any brothers (two older sisters), I can tell you that guys in general tend to resolve conflicts by fighting, so I agree with your reasoning. Again, great job!
ReplyDeletegood job with your retelling. Though you changed the names and the contest you did a great job of keeping the moral of the story intact. While you made the event a fight instead of a race yous still were able to make the outcome about being outwitted rather than losing a fight which is another aspect of this story that is important. Overall I would say you did a great job.
ReplyDeleteLillian,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed getting to read your version of Tortoise Bowl-On-The-Back. As you know, I also re-wrote that same story. I really enjoyed your version and it was great to see how you changed the story and compare it to how I changed the story. You did a great job and I look forward to reading more of your stories in the future.
Wow!! Your story was so good!! I love how you kept the moral of the story! It was really cool seeing how you rewrote the story! I really like how the father took part and helped Emmett win the fight. Your author's note was really good too! I like how it was very detailed and you put your reasoning for rewriting the story. Good job!
ReplyDeleteI loved this story! I really like how you created a story with actual people in it, while still sticking true to the original story. Having the story be told about humans versus animals makes it really relatable. Your author's note was extremely informative! After reading it I completely understood where you got your inspiration from.
ReplyDeleteGreat job all around!
I really liked your storytelling post from week five. The flow of your story was really nice and I liked your incorporation of dialogue between characters. I think it really added to the story and made your characters seem more alive! I also thought your author’s note was well written and provided a lot of context for the basis of your story.
ReplyDelete